Papers
Total Papers: 12465
Non-Peer-Reviewed Papers: 186
Not Climate Related Papers: 288
No Abstract: 47
Remaining Peer-reviewed Papers: 11944Global Climate Change papers: 3056
Global Warming papers: 9183
Global Warming & Global Climate Change papers: 295
Endorsements
Endorsement Papers
1 64
2 922
3 2910
4 7970
5 54
6 15
7 9
Endorsements: 3896 (32.6%)
Neutrals: 7970 (66.7%)
Rejections: 78 (0.7%)
Journals of climate-related, peer-reviewed papers: 1980
Authors
Authors of No Position Papers 18966 (64.8%)
Authors of Rejection Papers 101 (0.3%)
Authors of Rejection & Endorsement Papers 23 (0.1%)
Authors of Endorsement Papers 10188 (34.8%)
Notice: Undefined offset: 4 in /mnt/stor9-wc1-dfw1/652629/676685/www.welloiledcatherd.org/web/content/tcp_results.php on line 1840
8 (0.0%)
Total Authors: 29286Self-Ratings
Total Emails: 8547
Total Bounces: 0
Total Respondents (including authors of non-peer-reviewed papers): 1200
Response Rate: 14.040014040014%
Total papers self-rated: 2142
Table 5: Self-Ratings compared to Abstract Ratings
| Position | Abstract Rating | Self-Rating |
| Endorse AGW |
791 (36.9%) |
1342 (62.7%) |
| No AGW Position |
1339 (62.5%) |
761 (35.5%) |
| Reject AGW |
12 (0.6%) |
39 (1.8%) |
| Total |
2142 |
2142 |
Authors of No Position Papers 415 (34.9%)
Authors of Rejection Papers 23 (1.9%)
Authors of Rejection & Endorsement Papers 5 (0.4%)
Authors of Endorsement Papers 746 (62.7%)
Notice: Undefined offset: 4 in /mnt/stor9-wc1-dfw1/652629/676685/www.welloiledcatherd.org/web/content/tcp_results.php on line 1981
8 (0.7%)
Total Authors: 1189Consensus - Abstract Ratings
Level of PBL consensus for different TCP Bias
0 = no position, 1 = rejection, 2 = rejection+endorsement, 3 = endorsement
0: 600 out of 701 (86%)
1: 3 out of 14 (21%)
2: 1 out of 4 (25%)
3: 618 out of 666 (93%)
Consensus - Self Ratings
Level of PBL consensus for different TCP Bias
0 = no position, 1 = rejection, 2 = rejection+endorsement, 3 = endorsement
0: 122 out of 139 (88%)
1: 3 out of 15 (20%)
2: 2 out of 2 (100%)
3: 302 out of 319 (95%)
Self-Endorsements
| Endorsement | Cat | Qty |
| 1.0000 |
2 |
7 |
| 2.0000 |
2 |
20 |
| 2.5000 |
2 |
1 |
| 3.0000 |
2 |
15 |
| 4.0000 |
2 |
14 |
| 5.0000 |
2 |
1 |
| 1.0000 |
3 |
1 |
| 2.0000 |
3 |
4 |
| 3.0000 |
3 |
4 |
| 4.0000 |
3 |
2 |
Klaus-Martin Schulte
Schulte result 2003 to Feb 2007
Explicit with Quantification collapsed with Explicit without Quantification
'global climate change' papers found from 2003 to Feb 2007: 529
Eliminated papers: 24
Self-rated papers: 58
1.0000: 3
1.6670: 1
2.0000: 14
2.5000: 1
3.0000: 16
4.0000: 22
7.0000: 1
| Level of Endorsement | Schulte's Result | TCP Result (2003 to 2007) |
| 2. Explicitly endorses but does not quantify or minimise | 38 | 27 |
| 3. Implicitly endorses AGW without minimising it | 206 | 74 |
| 4. No Position | 264 | 401 |
| 5. Implicitly minimizes/rejects AGW | 25 | 3 |
| 6. Explicitly minimizes/rejects AGW but does not quantify | 6 | 0 |
| Total | 539 | 505 |