Id,Year,Title,Journal,Final Category,Final Endorsement,Rater 1,Category 1,Endorsement 1,Comment 1,Rater 2,Category 2,Endorsement 2,Comment 2,Rater 3,Category 3,Endorsement 3,Comment 3,Tie-break Rater,Tie-break Category,Tie-break Endorsement,Tie-break Comment
4018,1993,A Catalytic Process For The Decomposition Of Nitrous-oxide,Catalysis Today,3,4,1375,3,4,,873,3,4,I agree with neutral,,,,,,,,,
2677,1993,A General Relationship Between Co2-induced Reductions In Stomatal Conductance And Concomitant Increases In Foliage Temperature,Environmental And Experimental Botany,2,4,1375,2,4,,3364,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4076,1993,A Guide To Global Warming Potentials (gwps),Energy Policy,4,3,4194,4,3,,1375,4,3,Agreed with other reviewer. Moved to methods since GWP is applied to more than just mitigation. Uses GWP| but links it directly to heating effects > implicit.,,,,,,,,,
4009,1993,A Model Study Of Atmospheric Temperatures And The Concentrations Of Ozone| Hydroxyl| And Some Other Photochemically Active Gases During The Glacial| The Preindustrial Holocene And The Present,Geophysical Research Letters,5,3,1439,5,3,,873,5,3,I agree with paleoclimate,,,,,,,,,
3967,1993,A New Cloche Design For Elevating Temperature In Polar Terrestrial Ecosystems,Polar Biology,4,4,1,4,4,,1439,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
4010,1993,A New Perspective On Recent Global Warming - Asymmetric Trends Of Daily Maximum And Minimum Temperature,Bulletin Of The American Meteorological Society,4,4,3364,4,4,"linkages of T to large scale forcings such as anthro GHG remain tentative" = neutral (qualified/minimized),1802,4,2,clearly states anthropogenic increases,,,,,1,4,4,tentative = neutral,
4060,1993,A Possible Mechanism Relating Increased Soil-temperature To Forest Decline,Water Air And Soil Pollution,2,4,677,2,4,,1,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4033,1993,A Preliminary Note On Rainfall And Vegetation Trends In The South-western Cape - 1985-1988,South African Journal Of Botany,2,4,1439,2,4,,71,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4029,1993,A Proposal For The Classification Of Toxic-substances Within The Framework Of Life-cycle Assessment Of Products,Chemosphere,3,3,1375,3,3,,1439,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
4062,1993,A Reexamination Of The Polar Halocline Catastrophe And Implications For Coupled Ocean Atmosphere Modeling,Journal Of Physical Oceanography,4,4,1802,4,4,,1439,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
3954,1993,A Uk Greenhouse-gas Inventory - On Estimating Anthropogenic And Natural Sources And Sinks,Ambio,3,4,873,3,4,I think this relates more to mitigation than methods. Almost implicit endorsement,3364,4,4,on the boarder neutral/implicit endorsement. ,,,,,2103,3,4,lean toward mitigation classification,
4040,1993,Absence Of Scientific Basis,Research & Exploration,2,6,677,2,6,,1439,2,6,,,,,,,,,,
4016,1993,Agricultural Impacts Of And Responses To Climate-change In The Missouri-iowa-nebraska-kansas (mink) Region,Climatic Change,2,3,1439,2,3,,3083,2,3,,,,,,,,,,
3983,1993,Agriculture And Global Warming,Agriculture Ecosystems & Environment,4,4,677,4,4,,1,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
2688,1993,Agriculture In A Greenhouse World,Research & Exploration,2,2,677,2,2,,2103,2,2,,,,,,,,,,
2702,1993,Agriculture| Food And The Environment,Food Research International,2,3,3364,2,3,,1439,2,3,,,,,,,,,,
2673,1993,Air-pollution-mediated Changes In Alpine Ecosystems And Ecotones,Ecological Applications,2,4,3364,2,4,,2103,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4015,1993,An Analysis Of Microclimatic Variation In A Suburban Environment,Atmospheric Environment Part B-urban Atmosphere,2,4,677,2,4,,3364,4,4,general comparisons of microclimates| not specifically an impact of GW,,,,,1,2,4,Results = Impacts,
2660,1993,An Empirical-analysis Of The Strength Of The Phytoplankton-dimethylsulfide-cloud-climate Feedback Cycle,Journal Of Geophysical Research-atmospheres,4,2,873,2,2,Somewhat borderline| but ok| I agree with explicit,3364,4,2,"a perturbation to the global climate| such as is anticipated due to accumulation of anthropogenic greenhouse gases." = explicit endorsement,,,,,2103,4,2,as with 1st rating,
3985,1993,An Overview Of Large-scale Co2 Disposal Options,Energy Conversion And Management,3,3,873,3,4,I agree that this is endorsement| so I update my rating to implicit endorsement. However| theres no explicit mention of AGW| so this is not explicit,71,3,2,"CO2 mitigation techniques as a response to the issue of global warming" | "CO2 produced from a range of fossil fuel fired power generation plant types|",,,,,2178,3,3,Not strong enough for explicit.,
4082,1993,Anomalous Seasonal Cycles Of Decapod Crustacean Larvae In The North-sea Plankton In An Abnormally Warm Year,Journal Of Experimental Marine Biology And Ecology,2,4,873,2,4,,1439,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
2665,1993,Aquatic Biomass And Carbon-dioxide Trapping,Energy Conversion And Management,3,3,2103,3,3,,1439,3,3,CC "has been linked" to excess CO2| is not explicit,,,,,,,,,
2695,1993,Aquatic Biomass Resources And Carbon-dioxide Trapping,Biomass & Bioenergy,3,3,3364,3,3,,71,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
4079,1993,Arthropods As Disease Vectors In A Changing Environment,Ciba Foundation Symposia,2,4,4194,2,3,,677,2,4,,,,,,2103,2,4,No anthro implication,
2670,1993,Assessing The Effectiveness Of Marine Co2 Disposal,Energy Conversion And Management,3,3,3364,3,3,,677,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
3974,1993,Assessment Of The Atmospheric Hazards And Risks Of New Chemicals - Procedures To Estimate Hazard Potentials,Chemosphere,4,3,4194,4,3,,1,4,3,,,,,,,,,,
4024,1993,Automotive Emissions In Developing-countries - Relative Implications For Global Warming| Acidification And Urban Air-quality,Transportation Research Part A-policy And Practice,3,3,1683,2,2,doesn't state dominant = not category 1| but still explicit,1375,3,3,Says that human activities can cause warming| but doesn't state dominant effect. Therefore implicit.,,,,,1439,3,3,Implicit support of AGW but borderline explicit,
4005,1993,Basic Tendencies In Changes Of The Earths Vegetation In Relation To Global Warming Of The Climate,Russian Plant Physiology,2,4,873,2,4,Typo in relevant place in this case didn't affect rating,677,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4049,1993,Benign Greenhouse,Research & Exploration,4,5,1439,4,5,Problematic| ,873,4,5,I think this is methods| not impacts. Indeed problematic| but I have changed my rating| as I realized that this minimizes AGW,,,,,,,,,
4046,1993,Bipolar Mollusks And Their Evolutionary Implications,Journal Of Biogeography,5,4,677,8,4,,1,5,4,Evolution is climate related| hence paleo,,,,,2103,5,4,climate-relatedness discussed in abstract,
4068,1993,Can Fuel-based Energy-production Meet The Challenge Of Fighting Global Warming - A Chance For Biomass And Cogeneration,Bioresource Technology,3,3,3364,3,2,,1375,3,3,peer reviewed?,6319,3,3,,,,,,
4042,1993,Carbon-dioxide And Climate - The Impact Of Cloud Parameterization,Journal Of Climate,4,3,873,4,3,,3364,4,3,,,,,,,,,,
4080,1993,Chemical Pollution Of The Environment - Past| Present And Future,Ciba Foundation Symposia,3,3,1375,3,3,,1802,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
4073,1993,Climate Effects Of Atmospheric Methane,Chemosphere,2,3,677,3,3,,1375,2,3,Notes changes in human use would affect global warming. Moved to implicit due to strictness of 2.1. Left as impacts rather than mitigation because this doesn't fit guideline C2.1 or C2.2. Is looking at what would happen under different scenarios.,,,,,1439,2,3,Brderline Impacts/Mitigation: Introductory lsentence and title suggest "Impacts",
3997,1993,Climate Instability During The Last Interglacial Period Recorded In The Grip Ice Core,Nature,5,4,4194,5,4,,873,5,4,,,,,,,,,,
3948,1993,Climate-change And The Short-term Impact Of Feral House Mice At The Sub-antarctic Prince-edward-islands,Oecologia,2,4,873,2,4,,71,2,4,Mentions human impacts| but doesn,,,,,,,,,
2671,1993,Climate-change And Water-resource Availability - An Impact Assessment For Bombay And Madras| India,Water International,2,3,1802,2,3,,677,2,3,,,,,,,,,,
3984,1993,Co2 And Climatic-change - An Overview Of The Science,Energy Conversion And Management,4,2,3364,4,2,ok,873,4,2,Even if uncertainties are much highlighted here| the human contribution is stated clearly enough to make this explicit (old note: Peer-reviewed?),,,,,,,,,
4052,1993,Co2 Emissions Control - Comparing Policy Instruments,Energy Policy,3,3,2103,3,3,,1683,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
4077,1993,Combating Global Warming - Reducing Co2 Emissions From Coal-fired Power-plant,Proceedings Of The Institution Of Mechanical Engineers Part A-journal Of Power And Energy,3,3,1,3,3,,1683,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
3971,1993,Comparison Of Environmental Impacts Of Electricity From Different Sources,Nuclear Energy-journal Of The British Nuclear Energy Society,3,4,873,3,4,,1439,3,4,,,,,,,,,,
4039,1993,Degrees Of Certainty,Research & Exploration,2,2,677,2,2,,1802,2,2,,,,,,,,,,
4032,1993,Differential Growth-responses Of Cassiope-tetragona| An Arctic Dwarf-shrub| To Environmental Perturbations Among 3 Contrasting High Sites And Sub-arctic Sites,Oikos,2,4,1375,2,4,,1439,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
3957,1993,Does Fossil-fuel Combustion Lead To Global Warming,Energy,4,2,4194,4,2,,71,4,2,,,,,,,,,,
4061,1993,Does Recent Global Warming Suggest An Enhanced Greenhouse-effect,Climatic Change,4,4,873,4,4,,1439,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
2679,1993,Downscaling Of Global Climate-change Estimates To Regional Scales - An Application To Iberian Rainfall In Wintertime,Journal Of Climate,2,3,1375,2,3,,3364,2,2,agree with impacts; IPCC scenarios including BAU are explicit,,,,,2103,2,3,See guideline 1.2,
3962,1993,Effects Of Cyclone Waves On Massive Coral Assemblages On The Great-barrier-reef - Meteorology| Hydrodynamics And Demography,Coral Reefs,2,4,873,2,4,,1439,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
2698,1993,Effects Of Intensification Of Agricultural Practices On Emission Of Greenhouse Gases,Chemosphere,3,3,4194,3,4,,1683,3,3,GHGs implicated in climate change = implicit,,,,,3364,3,3,3.1, mentions climate linked to GHGs,
2703,1993,Energy And Carbon Emissions - Sub-saharan African Perspective,Energy Policy,3,3,4194,3,3,mention of "debate" means "mitigation policy debate",873,3,4,GHG - GW link is too vague here for me,,,,,3364,3,3,mentions GCC in the context of reducing GHGs= 3.1 implicit,
4067,1993,Energy And Environmental-management Information-systems,Applied Energy,3,4,3364,3,4,ok,873,3,4,GHGs not mentioned as a cause for GW. First sentence might imply it but not strongly enough for me,,,,,,,,,
2693,1993,Energy-balance Comparison Of Sorghum And Sunflower,Theoretical And Applied Climatology,2,4,4194,2,4,,3364,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4090,1993,Environmental And Economic-implications Of Small-scale Chp,Energy Policy,3,2,1375,3,2,,2103,3,2,,,,,,,,,,
4083,1993,Environmental Impacts Of Electricity Generated By Developing-countries - Issues| Priorities And Carbon-dioxide Emissions,Iee Proceedings-a-science Measurement And Technology,3,4,677,3,4,,1802,3,4,,,,,,,,,,
4085,1993,Environmental Impacts Of Electricity-generation - Some Public-policy Dimensions,Iee Proceedings-a-science Measurement And Technology,3,4,4194,3,4,,3364,3,3,3.1 ,,,,,2178,3,4,Not strong enough for implicit,
4084,1993,Environmental Impacts Of Nuclear-power - Past Experience And Future-prospects,Iee Proceedings-a-science Measurement And Technology,3,2,4194,3,2,,677,3,4,,,,,,2103,3,2,,
4087,1993,Environmental-impact Of European Papermaking - A Comparison Of Primary And Recycled Fiber Scenarios,Paperi Ja Puu-paper And Timber,3,3,1439,3,3,,3364,3,3,3.1| last line = GW,,,,,,,,,
2659,1993,Estimation Of Local Precipitation Statistics Reflecting Climate-change,Water Resources Research,2,3,677,2,3,,1375,2,3,Moved to implicit in agreement with other reviewer due to guideline 3.2 > implicit acceptance from using CO2 forced scenarios leading to warming.,,,,,,,,,
3992,1993,Estimations Of A Global Sea-level Trend - Limitations From The Structure Of The Psmsl Global Sea-level Data Set,Global And Planetary Change,2,3,873,2,3,No explicit mention of human role (quote given by other rater is implicit statement),3364,2,2,"GW expected as a consequence of increasing CO2 release",,,,,2103,2,3,No anthro mention,
3981,1993,Evaluations Of Fertilization Of The Oceans As A Countermeasure Of Co2 Problem,Kagaku Kogaku Ronbunshu,3,3,1,3,3,,873,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
3958,1993,Evidence On The Climate Impact Of Solar Variations,Energy,4,7,677,4,7,,4194,4,5,,,,,,2103,4,7,,
4055,1993,Evolution Of Darwin Finches Caused By A Rare Climatic Event,Proceedings Of The Royal Society Of London Series B-biological Sciences,2,4,677,2,4,,1375,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4044,1993,Exploring The Gap - Top-down Versus Bottom-up Analyses Of The Cost Of Mitigating Global Warming,Energy Policy,3,4,1802,3,3,,873,3,4,Discusses emission reductions without mentioning climate| neutral,,,,,71,3,4,Doesn't meet 3.1... doesn't tie emissions to GW.,
2681,1993,Facility For Studying The Effects Of Elevated Carbon-dioxide Concentration And Increased Temperature On Crops,Plant Cell And Environment,2,4,677,2,4,,3083,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
3996,1993,Forest Wildfires As A Recent Source Of Co2 At Northern Latitudes,Canadian Journal Of Forest Research-revue Canadienne De Recherche Forestiere,4,4,4194,2,4,,873,4,3,Deals with fire impact on GW not with GW impact on fires = methods. Emissions (later elaborated as CO2) from fire as significant feedback to global warming = endorsement (although perhaps it would be good to have a mention of positive feedback here),,,,,2103,4,4,No implied human aspect here. ,
2685,1993,Forest-fires In Russia - Carbon-dioxide Emissions To The Atmosphere,Canadian Journal Of Forest Research-revue Canadienne De Recherche Forestiere,2,3,1439,2,3,,2103,2,3,,,,,,,,,,
4066,1993,Gas Emissions From Landfills And Their Contributions To Global Warming,Applied Energy,3,2,1802,3,2,,2001,3,2,Explicitly states methane from landfill goes to atmosphere and methane has been shown to contribute to global warming.,,,,,,,,,
3979,1993,Generation Of Greenhouse-effect Gases From Different Landfill Types,Engineering Geology,3,3,4194,4,3,,873,3,3,Emissions from landfill sites is a mitigation issue,,,,,1439,3,3,Measurements->Mitigation, not methods,
2658,1993,Global Climate-change And Agricultural Productivity In Southern Africa,Global Environmental Change-human And Policy Dimensions,2,4,71,2,4,,873,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
2682,1993,Global Climate-change And Terrestrial Net Primary Production,Nature,2,4,1683,2,4,,1,2,4,'effect of CO2 doubling and associated climate changes' is very close to implicit endorsement but err on side of neutral,,,,,,,,,
2683,1993,Global Climate-change| United-states Agriculture| And Carbon-dioxide,Journal Of Production Agriculture,3,3,1802,9,3,,1683,3,3,discusses mitigation (and impacts),3364,3,3,agriculture sequestering C,,,,,
4091,1993,Global Temperature Monitoring From Space,Global Change And Space Observations,4,4,1802,4,4,,873,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
3980,1993,Global Vegetation Change Predicted By The Modified Budyko Model,Climatic Change,2,2,4194,2,2,,1439,2,2,,,,,,,,,,
4086,1993,Global Warming - Trends And Effects,Parasitology,3,3,4194,3,3,,677,2,3,,,,,,2103,3,3,,
4011,1993,Global Warming And Forest-fires In Canada,Forestry Chronicle,2,4,1375,2,4,,677,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4017,1993,Global Warming And The Insurance Industry,Interdisciplinary Science Reviews,2,4,677,2,4,,873,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
3989,1993,Global Warming And The Internal Energy Market - Policy Integration Or Polarization,Energy Policy,3,4,1375,3,4,,1,3,4,,,,,,,,,,
4022,1993,Global Warming And The Problem Of Testing For Trend In Time-series Data,Journal Of Climate,4,4,1,4,4,Does it endorse the projections or just affirm that GHG projections exist?,873,4,4,Almost implicit rejection,,,,,,,,,
4051,1993,Global Warming From Chlorofluorocarbons And Their Alternatives - Time Scales Of Chemistry And Climate,Atmospheric Environment Part A-general Topics,2,3,3364,3,3,agree on implicit; but this is mitigation (need for reducing halocarbons) not impacts,1375,2,3,"is expected to" - too weak for explicit? Better fits guideline 3.2.,,,,,2178,2,3,Not just an analytical technique but conclusions from it = Impacts,
4007,1993,Global Warming Impacts Of Transport,Science Of The Total Environment,2,2,1802,2,2,,1375,2,2,,,,,,,,,,
2666,1993,Great-lakes Toxic Sediments And Climate-change - Implications For Environmental Remediation,Global Environmental Change-human And Policy Dimensions,2,4,873,2,4,,3364,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4088,1993,Greenhouse Gas Emissions| Abatement And Control - The Role Of Coal,Energy & Fuels,3,4,1439,3,4,,3364,3,4,,,,,,,,,,
4071,1993,Greenhouse Gases From Biomass And Fossil-fuel Stoves In Developing-countries - A Manila Pilot-study,Chemosphere,3,3,1802,4,3,,71,3,3,"Methods" only applies if no results are discussed. There are results. Further| they state "If verified| this could have substantial implications for energy and environmental policies in developing countries." - which to me means mitigation policies.,,,,,2103,3,3,Accept comments in 1st rating,
4048,1993,Greenhouse Policy,Research & Exploration,3,3,3364,3,3,,1375,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
4025,1993,Greenhouse-gas Emissions From The Use Of New Fuels For Transportation And Electricity,Transportation Research Part A-policy And Practice,3,3,1,3,3,"concern about global warming...examine alternate energy" = Implicit Endorse,873,3,4,They just say how many nations feel about it = neutral,,,,,1439,3,3,Rule 3.1, links emissions reduction to climate change,
4054,1993,Greenland - A Temptation And A Challenge,Endeavour,5,4,4194,4,3,,71,5,4,I don,,,,,1,5,4,Last glaciation = paleo. Not specific enough for an endorsement,
4035,1993,Groundwater Fluxes In The Global Hydrologic-cycle - Past| Present And Future,Journal Of Hydrology,2,3,1,2,3,ref to greenhouse warming,873,2,3,,,,,,,,,,
2687,1993,High-latitude Oceanic Variability Associated With The 18.6-year Nodal Tide,Journal Of Geophysical Research-oceans,4,4,677,4,4,,2001,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
4038,1993,How Sensitive Is The Worlds Climate,Research & Exploration,4,1,3364,4,1,,1,4,1,,,,,,,,,,
3999,1993,Human Influence In Geomorphology,Geomorphology,2,4,1227,2,4,,873,2,4,No cause for GW mentioned,,,,,,,,,
4043,1993,Implementation Of Greenhouse-gas Reductions In The European-community - Institutional And Cultural-factors,Global Environmental Change-human And Policy Dimensions,3,4,1802,3,4,,873,3,4,,,,,,,,,,
2689,1993,Indonesia And Global Climate-change Negotiations - Potential Opportunities And Constraints For Participation| Leadership| And Commitment,Global Environmental Change-human And Policy Dimensions,4,4,677,8,4,,1439,4,4,Definitely climate related,,,,,2103,4,4,See title accompanying abstract,
4008,1993,Infrared Cross-sections And Global Warming Potentials Of 10 Alternative Hydrohalocarbons,Journal Of Geophysical Research-atmospheres,4,4,1,4,4,GWP,3364,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
3960,1993,Insensitivity Of Global Warming Potentials To Carbon-dioxide Emission Scenarios,Nature,4,3,1802,4,3,,677,4,3,,,,,,,,,,
4037,1993,Lake Level Regulation And Shoreline Erosion On Flathead Lake| Montana - A Response To The Redistribution Of Annual Wave Energy,Journal Of Coastal Research,2,4,873,2,4,,1683,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4057,1993,Large Increases In Flood Magnitude In Response To Modest Changes In Climate,Nature,2,4,1439,2,4,,71,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4059,1993,Large-scale Dynamics And Global Warming,Bulletin Of The American Meteorological Society,2,4,3364,2,4,,1,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
3993,1993,Latest Paleocene Lithologic And Biotic Events In Neritic Deposits Of Southwestern New-jersey,Paleoceanography,5,4,1,5,4,,1683,5,4,,,,,,,,,,
4026,1993,Linked Simulation Of Land-use And Transportation Systems - Developments And Experience In The Puget Sound Region,Transportation Research Part A-policy And Practice,3,4,873,3,4,,677,3,4,,,,,,,,,,
2664,1993,Long-term Impacts Of Forest Treatments On Water Yield - A Summary For Northeastern Usa,Journal Of Hydrology,2,4,1439,2,4,,873,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4064,1993,Low-frequency Variability And Co2 Transient Climate Change .1. Time-averaged Differences,Climate Dynamics,2,3,1227,2,3,,3364,4,3,"time and space scales of climate anomalies"= methods,,,,,1439,2,3,study but with results C1.2=Impacts,
2690,1993,Managing The Global Climate-change Scientific Knowledge-base,Ai Applications,4,4,1439,4,4,,4194,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
4014,1993,Measurement Of The Retreat Of Qori Kalis Glacier In The Tropical Andes Of Peru By Terrestrial Photogrammetry,Photogrammetric Engineering And Remote Sensing,2,4,1,2,4,,3364,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4031,1993,Membrane-development For The Separation Of H-2 And Co2 - Screening-tests,Chemical Engineering Research & Design,3,3,1375,3,3,,677,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
4075,1993,Methane Emission From Arctic Tundra,Biogeochemistry,2,4,873,2,4,Almost implicit endorsement,1,2,4,methane feedback implies greenhouse warming,,,,,,,,,
2701,1993,Methane From Biomass Systems-analysis And Co2 Abatement Potential,Biomass & Bioenergy,3,4,1439,3,4,,873,3,4,No GHG temperature link is presented| neutral.,,,,,,,,,
4072,1993,Methane In Permafrost - Preliminary-results From Coring At Fairbanks| Alaska,Chemosphere,2,4,873,2,4,,677,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4000,1993,Model Simulations Of The Competing Climatic Effects Of So2 And Co2,Journal Of Climate,4,2,4194,3,3,,1683,4,2,GW from enhanged GHGs = explicit| talks models| not mitigation,,,,,2103,4,2,CO2 greenhouse warming+IPCC scenarios,
4063,1993,Modeling Effects Of Habitat Fragmentation On The Ability Of Trees To Respond To Climatic Warming,Biodiversity And Conservation,2,4,1683,2,3,assumed future warming = implicit,677,2,4,It only assumes future climate change| neutral to be conservative,,,,,1439,2,4,It only assumes future climate change, neutral to be conservative,
4021,1993,Modeling Sub-alpine Forest Dynamics As Influenced By A Changing Environment,Water Air And Soil Pollution,4,4,2103,4,4,,1439,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
3947,1993,Modeling The Production Of Dimethylsulfide During A Phytoplankton Bloom,Journal Of Geophysical Research-oceans,4,4,677,2,5,,3364,4,4,not an impact of GW (except in the context of a possible feedback); definitely NOT a rejection of AGW; the DMS theory may not be right| but it's not crackpot; studying it is legitimate. ,,,,,2103,4,4,No rejection here. Legitimate research,
4093,1993,Mos-1/mos-1b/ers-1/jers-1 Data Sets Of Sea-surface Temperature And Polar Ice Extent For Isy,Remote Sensing Of Earths Surface And Atmosphere,4,4,4194,4,3,typo - 'gaper' for 'paper',1375,4,4,No cause mentioned > neutral.,,,,,1439,4,4,No AGW mentioned,
4023,1993,Multicriteria Generation-expansion Planning With Global Environmental Considerations,Ieee Transactions On Engineering Management,3,3,1,3,3,,4194,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
4089,1993,New Power-production Technologies - Various Options For Biomass And Cogeneration,Bioresource Technology,3,3,3364,3,3,,873,3,3,I agree with implicit endorsement,,,,,,,,,
2694,1993,Nitrogen Biogeochemical Cycling In The Northwestern Indian-ocean,Deep-sea Research Part Ii-topical Studies In Oceanography,4,4,873,4,4,,2103,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
2672,1993,Numerical-models Of Weather And Climate,Plasma Physics And Controlled Fusion,4,4,2103,4,4,,677,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
3951,1993,Objective Identification Of Cyclones In Gcm Simulations,Journal Of Climate,2,4,873,2,4,,677,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
3961,1993,On The Cold Start Problem In Transient Simulations With Coupled Atmosphere-ocean Models,Climate Dynamics,4,3,1,4,3,They talk about 'global warming curves' in response to 'CO2 doubling' - I think this is sufficient for Implicit Endorsement,873,4,4,I cannot say based on this abstract if CO2 affects climate or not (they just discuss unsuccesful model response and cold start error but I see no mention of actual result of doubling)| so neutral is still my rating,,,,,1439,4,3,Implicit endorsement (just) but weak.,
4002,1993,Opportunities For Developing Specialty Chemicals And Advanced Materials From Coals,Fuel Processing Technology,3,3,1375,3,3,,3364,3,3,agree,,,,,,,,,
3991,1993,Paleoatmospheric Consequences Of Co2 Released During Early Cenozoic Regional Metamorphism In The Tethyan Orogen,Chemical Geology,5,3,677,5,3,,4194,5,4,,,,,,2103,5,3,Guideline 3.3,
3988,1993,Paleoecology| Past Climate Systems| And C3/c4photosynthesis,Chemosphere,5,3,1375,5,4,methods?,1439,5,3,Links CO2 to past climate -->Implicit (3.3),,,,,2103,5,3,Guideline 3.3,
2675,1993,Paleozoic Atmospheric Co2 - Importance Of Solar-radiation And Plant Evolution,Science,5,3,71,5,3,,873,5,3,,,,,,,,,,
4004,1993,Pluvial Conditions In The Eastern Sahara Following The Penultimate Deglaciation - Implications For Changes In Atmospheric Circulation Patterns With Global Warming,Palaeogeography Palaeoclimatology Palaeoecology,5,4,4194,5,4,,3364,5,4,,,,,,,,,,
4045,1993,Policy Analysis Of The Greenhouse-effect - An Application Of The Page Model,Energy Policy,3,3,873,3,3,,4194,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
3963,1993,Polyurethanes And The Environment,Kautschuk Gummi Kunststoffe,3,4,873,3,4,,677,3,4,,,,,,,,,,
2662,1993,Pools And Fluxes Of Biogenic Carbon In The Former Soviet-union,Water Air And Soil Pollution,3,3,3364,3,3,,4194,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
3949,1993,Postfire Vegetation Recovery And Tree Establishment At The Arctic Treeline - Climate-change Vegetation-response Hypotheses,Journal Of Ecology,2,4,1439,2,4,,3364,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
3946,1993,Potential Chlorofluorocarbon Replacements - Oh Reaction-rate Constants Between 250 And 315-k And Infrared-absorption Spectra,Journal Of Geophysical Research-atmospheres,3,4,1227,3,4,,873,3,4,I agree with mitigation,,,,,,,,,
4027,1993,Potential Contributions Of Intelligent Vehicle Highway Systems (ivhs) To Reducing Tranportations Greenhouse Gas-production,Transportation Research Part A-policy And Practice,3,3,1227,3,3,,1439,3,3,Not explicit enough| I think,,,,,,,,,
2678,1993,Potential Effects Of Climate-change On A Semi-permanent Prairie Wetland,Climatic Change,2,3,873,2,3,,3364,2,3,ok,,,,,,,,,
3987,1993,Potential Limits Of Human Dominated Fossil Energy-based Global Ecosystems,Chemosphere,3,2,1375,3,3,,71,3,2,Human emissions| link made between emissions and warming: "The present sharp rise in CO2| driven mainly by the comparatively rapid combustion of fossil carbon,,,,,2103,3,2,See 1st rating comment,
4034,1993,Predicting Biological Response To Global Warming - A Laboratory Activity To Promote Discussion,American Biology Teacher,2,3,1683,2,3,doesn't mention anthro = implicit,677,2,2,the abstract is (now?) there,,,,,1439,2,3,doesn't mention anthro = implicit,
3990,1993,Predicting The Effects Of Global Warming On Terrestrial Ecosystems By Charbon Cycle Model,Kagaku Kogaku Ronbunshu,2,3,4194,2,4,,71,2,3,They draw the connection between GHG's and CC - "The effect of climate change by the increase of atmospheric carbon dioxide" - but don't expressly stipulate that the change is warming. Borderline.,3364,2,4,no mention of anthro effects; ,1,2,3,'cc by...CO2' = Implicit endorsement,
2674,1993,Projected Global Climate-change Impact On Water Temperatures In 5 North Central United-states Streams,Climatic Change,2,3,1375,2,2,climate change OR OTHER HUMAN...,873,2,3,This is implicit: "other" implies that climate change also is "human activity"| so its not explicitly stated,,,,,2103,2,3,I think this is implicit wording is open to interpretation,
3994,1993,Rain-forest Trees As A New Crop For Australia,Forest Ecology And Management,2,4,873,2,4,,677,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
3975,1993,Rate Coefficients For Reactions Of Several Hydrofluorocarbons With Oh And O((1)d) And Their Atmospheric Lifetimes,Journal Of Physical Chemistry,4,2,4194,4,2,,1802,4,2,,,,,,,,,,
4019,1993,Recent Warming - Ice Core Evidence From Tropical Ice Cores With Emphasis On Central-asia,Global And Planetary Change,2,4,2103,2,4,,3364,2,4,short ice cores| 50-100 years --> not paleo;,,,,,,,,,
3986,1993,Reducing Atmospheric Co2 Using Biomass Energy And Photobiology,Energy Conversion And Management,3,3,677,3,3,,4194,3,4,,,,,,2103,3,3,Guideline 3.1,
2700,1993,Response Of The Terrestrial Biosphere To Global Climate Change And Human Perturbation,Vegetatio,4,4,4194,4,2,,1375,2,3,Talks of human effects on land carbon storage| but not directly on warming| so left as implicit. Borderline methods/impacts| but talks about climate impacts on carbon sinks so left as impacts too.,,,,,3364,4,4,tile suggests impacts, but also impacts of humans on climate-> methods is a better fit; human effects on storage, not on CO2, climate = neutral,
4078,1993,Response Of The Thermal Structure Of Lake-ontario To Deep Cooling Water Withdrawals And To Global Warming,Journal Of Great Lakes Research,3,3,3364,3,3,ok,677,3,3,I rated it "mitigation" because they propose a way to avoid electric consumption,,,,,,,,,
2680,1993,Satellite Observation Of Lake Ice As A Climate Indicator - Initial Results From Statewide Monitoring In Wisconsin,Photogrammetric Engineering And Remote Sensing,4,3,873,4,3,,677,4,3,,,,,,,,,,
4030,1993,Sea-level Rise - Destruction Of Threatened And Endangered Species Habitat In South-carolina,Environmental Management,2,3,873,2,3,,1439,2,3,,,,,,,,,,
4013,1993,Sensitivity Of Tropical Cyclone Intensity To Sea-surface Temperature,Journal Of Climate,4,4,4194,4,4,,3364,4,4,agree,,,,,,,,,
3950,1993,Simplified Dynamic-model On Carbon Exchange Between Atmosphere And Terrestrial Ecosystems,Ecological Modelling,4,4,677,4,4,,2001,4,4,Though linking climate change to increasing CO2 is pretty much implicit endosrement,,,,,,,,,
3956,1993,Simulating Past And Forecasting Future Climates,Environmental Conservation,4,6,3364,4,7,"climate will not warm in next 50 years"| will start cooling soon. ,71,4,6,,,,,,2178,4,6,Left it as methds but might almost be opinion. Not clear cut enough for 7since it is so waffly,
4058,1993,Soil Warming And Trace Gas Fluxes - Experimental-design And Preliminary Flux Results,Oecologia,4,4,3364,4,4,feedbacks,677,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
4028,1993,Solar-hydrogen Fuel-cell Vehicles,Transportation Research Part A-policy And Practice,3,3,4194,3,3,,1439,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
3972,1993,Spatial And Temporal Analysis Of Middle-eastern Temperature-changes,Climatic Change,2,4,4194,2,4,,1683,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
3976,1993,Stabilizing United-states Net Carbon Emissions By Planting Trees,Energy Conversion And Management,3,4,873,3,4,,1683,3,4,,,,,,,,,,
3952,1993,Statistical Dependence Of Albedo And Cloud Cover On Sea-surface Temperature For 2 Tropical Marine Stratocumulus Regions,Journal Of Climate,2,4,1375,2,4,POSITIVE FEEDBACK,1,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
2668,1993,Storage And Utilization Of Co2 In Petroleum Reservoirs - A Simulation Study,Energy Conversion And Management,3,2,1683,3,2,,71,3,2,,,,,,,,,,
4053,1993,Structural Comparison Of The Models In Emf-12,Energy Policy,3,3,4194,3,3,economics of carbon-free markets,1683,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
4092,1993,Technical Options For Energy-conservation And Controlling Environmental-impact In Highway Vehicles,International Journal Of Vehicle Design,3,4,1375,3,4,,1439,3,4,,,,,,,,,,
2669,1993,Technological Considerations For Planning The Global Carbon Future,Energy Conversion And Management,3,2,1802,3,2,,873,3,2,First sentence is quite explicit endorsement,,,,,,,,,
3973,1993,Temporal Variation In Growth-rate And Age At Maturity Of Male Painted Turtles| Chrysemys-picta,American Midland Naturalist,2,4,1683,2,4,,1439,2,4,No carbon emissions or AGW mentioned. ,,,,,,,,,
3977,1993,The Carbon And Energy Budgets Of Energy Crops,Energy Conversion And Management,3,2,677,3,2,,71,3,2,,,,,,,,,,
3969,1993,The Carbon-cycle And Global Forest Ecosystem,Water Air And Soil Pollution,4,4,3364,4,4,qualifying C-cycle| not an impact of GW,677,2,4,Per C1.2 it's not method,,,,,2178,4,4,Analysing the C-Cycle; not suggesting an impact from it.,
2699,1993,The Current Status Of Operational Satellite Products For Climate Studies,Global Change And Space Observations,4,4,1967,4,2,,71,4,4,Frustrating| because I think it is more than Neutral| but there is no discussion of GHG's| no link of GHG's to climate| or GHG's to human activity.,,,,,1439,4,4,Frustrating, because I think it is more than Neutral, but there is no discussion of GHG's, no link of GHG's to climate, or GHG's to human activity.,
2691,1993,The Dilemma Of Fossil-fuel Use And Global Climate Change,Energy & Fuels,3,4,677,3,2,,873,3,4,Apparent endorsement here is stated neutrally so that it is very uncertain if they endorse or not,,,,,1683,3,4,too wishy washy to count as endorsement,
2697,1993,The Effect Of Soil-moisture And Thaw Depth On Ch4 Flux From Wet Coastal Tundra Ecosystems On The North Slope Of Alaska,Chemosphere,2,4,1439,2,4,,3364,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4041,1993,The Global Temperature Data,Research & Exploration,4,6,3364,4,6,,1683,4,6,,,,,,,,,,
2692,1993,The Impacts Of Climate Change On Rice Yield - A Comparison Of 4 Model Performances,Ecological Modelling,2,3,3364,2,3,,2103,2,3,,,,,,,,,,
3995,1993,The Lowland-to-upland Transition Modeling Plant-responses To Environmental-change,Ecological Applications,2,4,1439,2,4,,1802,2,4,,,,,,,,,,
4069,1993,The Net Greenhouse Warming Forcing Of Methanol Produced From Biomass,Biomass & Bioenergy,3,3,4194,3,3,,1439,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
3982,1993,The Plankton Multiplier - Positive Feedback In The Greenhouse,Journal Of Plankton Research,2,2,873,2,2,,2103,2,2,,,,,,,,,,
4074,1993,The Potential Effects Of Climate Change On Summer Season Dairy-cattle Milk-production And Reproduction,Climatic Change,4,4,2103,4,4,,1683,4,4,,,,,,,,,,
2663,1993,The Potential Response Of Global Terrestrial Carbon Storage To A Climate-change,Water Air And Soil Pollution,2,3,677,2,3,,1439,2,3,,,,,,,,,,
3953,1993,The Relationship Between Global Warming And Methane Gas Hydrates In The Earth,Chemical Engineering Science,2,3,873,2,3,,3364,2,3,4.1| no indication that increase is anthro; on second thought| this fits 3.2,,,,,,,,,
4036,1993,The Significance Of Marginopora-vertebralis (foraminifera) In Surficial Sediments At Esperance| Western-australia| And In Last Interglacial Sediments In Northern Spencer Gulf| South Australia,Marine Geology,5,4,873,5,4,,1375,5,4,,,,,,,,,,
4003,1993,The Technical Challenges For Solid Desiccant Cooling,Heat Recovery Systems & Chp,3,3,1967,8,3,,3364,3,3,reducing GHG emissions = mitigation,,,,,1227,3,3,discusses reduced electricity demand & GHG emissions -> mitigation,
4012,1993,The Theory Of Energy Return On Investment - A Case-study Of Whole Tree Chipping For Biomass In Prince-edward-island,Forestry Chronicle,3,3,4194,3,3,,1802,3,3,,,,,,,,,,
4056,1993,The Transient-response Of Terrestrial Carbon Storage To A Perturbed Climate,Nature,2,3,1683,2,3,,873,2,3,I agree with impacts,,,,,,,,,
2661,1993,Tm-landsat Imagery Applied To The Study Of The Impact Of Global Climate-change On A Tropical Coastal Environment During The Last Deglaciation,International Journal Of Remote Sensing,5,4,873,5,4,No used search phrases in abstract,1439,5,4,,,,,,,,,,
3966,1993,Total Equivalent Warming Impact - A Measure Of The Global Warming Impact Of Cfc Alternatives In Refrigerating Equipment,International Journal Of Refrigeration-revue Internationale Du Froid,3,3,4194,3,4,,873,3,3,GW impacts of co2 emssions from fossil fuels is endorsement,,,,,2103,3,3,'important alternative technologies do not exacerbate GW',
4020,1993,Tropical Forest Changes During The Late Quaternary In African And South-american Lowlands,Global And Planetary Change,5,4,1439,5,4,,3364,5,4,,,,,,,,,,
3970,1993,Tropospheric Ozone And Climate-change,Journal Of The Air & Waste Management Association,4,3,1802,4,3,,873,4,3,Says that ozone has impact on global warming,,,,,,,,,
3959,1993,Uncertainties In Carbon-dioxide Radiative Forcing In Atmospheric General-circulation Models,Science,4,3,873,4,3,,71,4,3,,,,,,,,,,
3955,1993,United-states Demilitarization And Global Warming - An Empirical-investigation Of The Environmental Peace Dividend,Energy Policy,3,4,1439,3,4,,873,3,4,This is not about impact of GW| it is more about how GW is impacted by US budget,,,,,,,,,
2686,1993,Use Of General-circulation Model Output In The Creation Of Climate-change Scenarios For Impact Analysis .1.,Climatic Change,4,3,1439,2,3,,873,4,3,Creation of climate change scenarios = methods| even if they might get used by impact studies,,,,,3364,4,3,how to apply global models for regional use = methods,
3978,1993,Utilization Of Carbon-dioxide From Fossil-fuel - Burning Power-plants With Biological-systems,Energy Conversion And Management,3,4,677,3,3,,1375,3,4,Mentions CO2 reduction| but is not linked to global warming. By guideline 3.1 this is not an implicit endorsement.,,,,,3364,3,4,no link to climate,
4065,1993,Water-vapor And Its Role In The Earths Greenhouse,Australian Journal Of Physics,4,4,1802,4,4,,1375,4,4,,,,,,,,,,